River Municipal Advisory Council

ONE YEAR AGO — Members of the Lower Russian River Municipal Advisory Council were sworn into office in Guerneville last February. They are, from left to right, Cynthia Strecker, Jeanette Dillman, Lucy Hardcastle, Jordan Lebovich, Mike Nicholls, Pip Marquez de la Plata, Jeniffer Wertz, Claudia Sisomphou and Vesta Copestakes.

Lower Russian River Municipal Advisory Council (MAC) will celebrate its first year in existence next Thursday, Feb. 20, when the MAC meets in the El Molino High School library starting at 5:30 p.m.

“We’re going to talk about progress,” said Elise VanDyne, field representative for Sonoma County’s Fifth District Supervisor Lynda Hopkins.

MAC’s nine elected members will get an annual report on their inaugural year’s activities and look at how the MAC wants to proceed in its role as the advisory body for Fifth District Supervisor Lynda Hopkins, said VanDyne.

Discussions of local flood recovery resources, tourism impact fund expenditures and how issues are supposed to get on the MAC’s agendas will be on the table next week. Plus, the council will also elect its first chair and vice chair,

“It’s an interesting agenda. We have a lot to get done,” said VanDyne, who last July took over the field rep job that includes facilitating the river MAC’s six annual meetings.

Lower River MAC challenges last year included February’s flood disaster, several staff turnovers in Hopkins’ Fifth District office and the MAC’s inexperience.

Thus far, “Guidance has not been consistent and strong,” VanDyne said, “but there are a lot of good things happening.”

The MAC spent much of 2019 reacting to the February Russian River flood, the worst Russian River flood disaster in more than two decades. MAC members now hope to move forward, making recommendations on new projects such as appropriate local uses for Sonoma County Tourism Impact Mitigation Funds (TIF).

MAC also needs clarity on when and how county use permit applications, such as a controversial housing development proposed on River Road along the Rio Nido strip, will get reviewed by the MAC.

So far “We haven’t set any guidelines” for putting local use permit applications on MAC’s agenda, said VanDyne.

She said that what MAC should or should not be reviewing is still being worked out. For instance a proposal for the river MAC to form an ad hoc oversight committee to review non-profit social service spending on Guerneville homelessness failed to gain support at the MAC’s last meeting in December.

Guerneville resident and MAC member Jeniffer Wertz has proposed the homelessness review as a way to address issues with programs such as the West County Community Services winter shelter that brings people in for nightly food and shelter in the Guerneville Vets Hall, but then scatters the homeless out on the street every morning to congregate downtown.

“I wanted to get a group of local citizens looking at statistics and dollar amounts” for local homelessness services to see if they are working or not, said Wertz,

“Right now they are not collecting that data,” said Wertz. “How many people are coming here from out of town? How many law enforcement calls” are related to homelessness?

For downtown merchants, “There’s no nuisance resolution process,” said Wertz.

But VanDyne said that MAC “is not an oversight council” for private non-profit endeavors such as the winter shelter.

Lynda Hopkins made the formation of a Lower Russian River MAC for citizen participation a key component of her 2016 campaign for county supervisor. The MAC’s elected members represent seven lower river districts: Forestville, Hacienda, Pocket Canyon, Rio Nido, Guerneville, Monte Rio and Cazadero.

After a year on the job, “We really don’t know each other,” said one MAC member who wasn’t speaking for attribution. “We’re still trying to get everyone on the same tack.”

Recent meetings have felt “directionless,” said a MAC observer. A long all-day December retreat, which included members from the separate Sonoma Coast MAC, began with everyone doing yoga exercises.

That’s when “I knew the day was going to be a disaster,” said a MAC attendee. “It was a lot of psycho babble and game playing.”

(2) comments


I'm not sure if it's the way this article is written but it comes across as if the concerns around homelessness are not being addressed. Yet, it seems that would be one area where local residents and merchants would want to be heard to give input, solutions and recommendations. Isn't one of the MAC's primary purposes to address local concerns and issues that are impacting their day-to-day experiences?

Frank in Guernewood

Well, that is certainly a disappointing start for this LRR MAC. I'm attending their next meeting on the 20th, and really hope other members of the local community can, too. It'll be interesting, given the past year, to hear what these LRR MAC members detail as accomplishments. Given the state of Guerneville and surrounding area, I cannot understand why on God's Green Earth this LRR MAC hasn't addressed a single problem we have been dealing with. I, for one, had high hopes for this Council, processes identified in the start-up meetings, and real potential of what could happen to address area concerns. The comment made in the article re "not knowing each other" and "yoga" at a retreat boggles my humble mind. Yet, reading what other area MACs (The Coast MAC) have accomplished, I am not without hope that something good can come of this process. Indeed, it will be illuminating to hear just how agenda items are arrived at. One final note, I am reminded that this IS a new process, and the LRR MAC members ARE elected volunteers, so the Community should attend the meetings, perhaps to provide some input. Who's with me??

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.